Are Crypto Income ETFs Really Profitable? Analyzing The Booming TradFi Trend
Original story by: BeInCrypto
Last updated: Oct 22, 2025
Ad
- Context: The article examines the evolving landscape of cryptocurrency Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs), specifically focusing on "crypto income ETFs" and "crypto stock ETFs." It highlights the desire of traditional investors for crypto exposure with reduced volatility, contrasting this with the performance and risks associated with these newer ETF products.
Ad
Ad
- Detailed Summary:
- The first wave of crypto ETFs enabled traditional investors to access crypto assets.
- Cryptocurrencies remain highly volatile, as evidenced by recent large leveraged wipeouts and the FTX collapse.
- Investors seek products that mitigate extreme price swings, even at the cost of potentially lower upside.
- A new wave of crypto ETFs, including "income" and "stock" variants, are emerging with higher fees and more active management.
- Crypto income ETFs aim to provide income alongside potential crypto upside, but often use futures contracts instead of holding the underlying crypto.
- Income generation in these ETFs can occur through selling short-dated futures against long-dated ones, leveraging price swings.
- While some income ETFs, like ProShares Bitcoin ETF (BITO), have shown high dividend yields (e.g., over 50% annualized), their total returns can be negative (e.g., BITO down nearly 20% year-to-date) compared to the underlying asset.
- The use of futures involves a "time premium that decays," which can lead to significant losses, especially in sideways or bear markets.
- Leverage exacerbates these losses; for example, the Defiance Leveraged Long Income Ethereum ETF (ETHI) dropped 30% in its first few weeks.
- Currently, crypto income ETFs appear designed for bull markets and may not perform well in other market conditions.
- Crypto stock ETFs, which hold shares of crypto-related companies (e.g., mining firms, MicroStrategy, Visa, Coinbase), offer some diversification.
- However, these ETFs also face volatility and have shown mixed results. The REX Crypto Equity Premium Income ETF (CEPI) has shown positive total returns despite share volatility, while the YieldMax Crypto Industry Portfolio Option Income ETF (LFGY) is down since inception and struggles to attract investors.
- Despite increased mainstream integration, cryptocurrency volatility remains a significant concern for investors.
- Investors often prefer the upside potential without enduring substantial drawdowns.
- While crypto income ETFs provide income, they are currently failing to preserve capital over time, which is a key issue.
- Increased competition in the ETF space may lead to improved returns.
- For crypto enthusiasts, direct ownership of the underlying asset is still recommended.
- For investors seeking crypto exposure with reduced risk, spot ETFs that hold the actual cryptocurrency are presented as the most viable option currently.
Ad
Ad